Here is a number that cuts through the whole right-to-repair debate in one stroke: American drivers are paying an extra $12 billion a year for car repairs because modern vehicles are software-gated. The Register's Dan Robinson ran the figures this weekend, and they are worth sitting with, because this is not really a story about cars. It is a story about who is allowed to fix the things we own, and what happens when the answer is nobody without a subscription.

Where the money goes

The problem is that today's vehicles increasingly need proprietary software tools before a mechanic can do anything at all, from diagnosing a fault to replacing a part, and those tools live behind paywalls. Add the subscriptions carmakers now charge for features the hardware already supports, and the cost ripples outward: repairs get pricier, insurers price in the digital lock-in, and drivers pay again through inflated premiums. Twelve billion dollars a year, straight out of consumers' pockets, for the privilege of owning a computer on wheels that you are not allowed to fully use. Source: https://www.theregister.com/personal-tech/2026/11/22/as-cars-go-digital-us-consumers-pay-an-extra-12-billion-a-year-for-repairs/5311412

We have seen this movie before

Fifteen years ago the poster child was not cars, it was the iPhone, and then it was John Deere tractors, where farmers were famously locked out of their own equipment during planting season. Each time, the pattern is identical: hardware gets better, software gets restrictive, the repair ecosystem that served owners for a century gets fenced off, and the bill lands on the people who actually bought the thing. Cars are simply the biggest stage the fight has reached, because almost everyone owns one and the sums are enormous.

The fix is already moving

The encouraging part is that this is one of the few tech-policy fights where the counterattack is well organised and winning real ground. US states have passed right-to-repair laws, Massachusetts voters forced carmakers to open diagnostic data by referendum, and the EU's repairability rules keep tightening the screws on anyone who wants to sell a sealed black box. Independent shops are building their own diagnostic stacks, and open standards for vehicle data access exist and work. The $12 billion figure gives every one of those campaigns a headline number to point at, and it is the kind of number legislators remember. Source: https://www.theregister.com/personal-tech/2026/11/22/as-cars-go-digital-us-consumers-pay-an-extra-12-billion-a-year-for-repairs/5311412

The takeaway for the rest of tech

Cars are the canary. The same playbook, hardware you buy but software you license, tools behind subscriptions, features rentable after purchase, is spreading through everything from printers to farm equipment to smart home gear. Every industry that tries it produces the same result: a growing tax on ownership and a repair market strangled at birth. The good news is that the remedy is proven and boring: mandated access, open diagnostics, parts and documentation. The car fight is simply where those remedies get their biggest test yet, and if drivers win it, every locked-down gadget becomes harder to defend. That is a fight worth watching, because $12 billion a year is just the opening bid.